Large pizza chains are under pressure due to weakening consumer spending, more dining options, and an increase in the use of GLP-1 drugs, which is dragging down sales.
During the pandemic, Domino's Pizza, Pizza Hut, Little Caesar's, and PepsiCo Pizza Hut all experienced a period of prosperity. However, since the resumption of in-person dining, America's largest pizza chains have been struggling to retain their customers.
Today, while consumers have control over their discretionary spending, they also have more options for takeout and delivery due to the easier accessibility through third-party platforms. In addition, food quality and customer experience have become more important to diners who are seeking value for their money.
Affected by "pizza fatigue" and broader challenges in the food service industry, the number of pizza restaurants in the United States has declined. According to data from Datassential, since reaching a peak of 83,035 pizza restaurants nationwide in August 2019, more than 9,600 pizza shops have closed as of July 2026.
Technomic data shows that in 2025, sales of pizza restaurants in the United States declined by 0.3%. Sales of independent pizza shops decreased by 0.4%. Chain stores account for about two-thirds of the total sales in the pizza category in the US, and their revenue also fell by 0.3%.
Bob's John announced that in 2025, same-store sales in North America decreased by 2.5%. Pizza Hut's same-store sales in the United States fell by 5%. Among the three pizza chains that were still publicly traded last year, only Domino's achieved annual same-store sales growth in its U.S. stores, with an increase of 3%.
Not only has consumer interest in pizza declined, but investors are also less enthusiastic now. Since March 2020, the stock price of Pizza Hut has fallen by about two-thirds. Even Domino's, which holds a dominant position, has only seen a stock price increase of about 2% during the same period. In contrast, the S&P 500 index has risen by about 150% over the same time frame.
In addition, this year Yum Brands sold Pizza Hut, divesting this business, which had been experiencing stagnant sales for a long time, to LongRange Capital and Yum China.
In a research report in September, Bank of America analyst Zachary Fadem wrote: "Pizza Hut has always been a drag on YUM... Looking ahead, YUM will no longer be hindered by pizza category dynamics (such as discounts), which will lead to stronger growth and a higher concentration in industries and markets with faster growth."
Challenges Faced by Pizza
Compared to 2020, pizza chains now face significantly more competition in competing for consumers' wallets. During the pandemic, popular third-party delivery platforms offered a much wider range of dishes than traditional pizzas and Chinese cuisine. As a result, Domino's and Pizza Hut have to compete with other fast-food chains such as McDonald's and Chick-fil-A for orders of DoorDash and Uber Eats.
As the price of pizza rises, its attractiveness to budget-conscious consumers decreases. According to the "2026 Pizza Power Report" published by the industry publication PMQ Pizza, the average price of a large cheese pizza has now approached $17.
In addition, frozen pizza is also a more convenient and cheaper option. NielsenIQ data shows that within the 52 weeks up to November 7th, the retail sales of single and multi-piece frozen pizzas increased by 2.9% compared to the same period in 2022.
Circana Consultant in the Food and Beverage Industry David Portalatin says: "When American consumers focus on the cheapest meal, the items in the pantry, refrigerator, and freezer always come out on top every time."
Convenience stores such as Casey's and General Stores have also won customers with their low-priced pizzas.
Bank of America securities analyst Sara Senatore wrote in a research report released in June: "We believe that Casey has an advantage over fast-food restaurants and dollar stores, as the latter two have fewer options to cope with in a context of ongoing inflation, while Casey can use profit margins to offset food cost pressures."
She added that the geographical overlap of the stores indicates that Casey is taking market share from Pizza Hut.
Large pizza chains have also been slow to adapt to consumers' new preferences for nutrition. For example, among the four major chains, only Domino's has attempted to add protein to its pizza crusts, and that test was only conducted for one day in a restaurant in Atlanta, as more diners are giving priority to protein in their diets.
From a broader nutritional perspective, pizza also has a negative impact on this category. The carbohydrates from the dough and the fat content from the cheese may reduce the interest of consumers who use GLP-1 medication, whereas the usage of such medications has seen a significant increase in the past few years.
A survey conducted by PwC in 2026 revealed that after using these medications for 6 to 8 months, the spending of GLP-1 families at pizza fast-food restaurants decreased by 22.2%.
However, the recent difficulties faced by pizza do not mean that this category is in a crisis of survival. According to Portalatin of Circana, the total number of pizzas sold this year has only decreased by about 1%.
Chain brands are also working hard to reverse this downward trend. In August, Domino's launched a customizable Detroit-style single-person pizza Domino aimed at attracting diners who eat alone. In November, Pizza Hut announced a new turnaround plan focusing on improving food consistency and store operations. Meanwhile, PepsiCo is offering discounts on holiday-themed packages.
Portalatin said, "Pizza will not disappear. American consumers love pizza."












