The USDA under the Trump administration changed regulations, and farmers and rural businesses paid the price
Fortune
1h ago
Ai Focus
This year, Sun Grants Consulting founder Veronica McFadden stated that she was forced to lay off all 5 of her employees because the U.S. Department of Agriculture first suspended the processing of REAP applications and then changed the qualification rules, resulting in damage to her clients' applications and expected income. The article criticizes this policy for turning subsidies intended for rural energy investment into a "reimbursement-style lottery" and questions whether it is consistent with the legislative intent of Congress.
Helpful
No.Help

This year, I was forced to lay off all 5 of my employees. My business wasn't ruined by competitors, nor did it fail due to a downturn in the market; instead, it was destroyed by a decision made by my own government.

In 2023, I founded Sun Grants Consulting to help farmers and small rural businesses apply for subsidies through the Rural Energy America Program (Rural Energy for America Program, commonly referred to as REAP). The company once grew to have 5 employees and submitted nearly 200 applications.

In March of this year, the United States Department of Agriculture announced that it would cease to process pending REAP applications and would not issue new grants until the new regulations took effect. Those who had submitted applications in accordance with the current rules would have to start over. Fifty-seven of my clients' applications were affected by this decision, involving rural energy investments of over $22 million and grant amounts of over $9 million. Since my company is only compensated after our clients receive their grants, the expected income from these applications has also disappeared.

In the 2002 Agricultural Act, Congress established REAP with the aim of encouraging investment in renewable energy and energy efficiency. This program has consistently received support from both parties, including reauthorization in the 2018 Agricultural Act signed by President Trump. REAP is not a "blank check": farmers and business owners put their own capital at risk, hire private contractors, and pay for costs that are not covered by subsidies.

Then came a second blow. In October, the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) issued a new rule that fundamentally changed how applicants would qualify in the future. Generally speaking, farmers and businesses had to complete projects, pay their bills, and record their energy production or savings over a 12-month period before they could apply. The USDA itself acknowledged that "there is some uncertainty as to whether they would receive rewards."

The U.S. Department of Agriculture turned an investment incentive into a reimbursement-style lottery. The companies that need help the most often lack the ability to risk their capital on subsidies that are decided only after a year or even longer.

Taking Ron Rusk, a dairy farmer from Michigan, as an example, I once helped him prepare the application for REAP. After applying according to the old rules, he invested about $86,000 in purchasing solar equipment, hoping to receive a subsidy that covered approximately a quarter of the cost. In March, the USDA's reverse transfer policy caused his application, which he had not yet completed, to come to a standstill, and in October, the new rules directly terminated his application.

The damage is not limited to the applicants alone. National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition estimates that for every $1 of REAP subsidy, there can be a total of $8.72 in project expenditures. This means that electricians, installers, manufacturers, and rural contractors all have work to do. The budget documents of the United States Department of Agriculture itself state that the REAP project can bring “new, sustainable sources of income” to farmers and small rural businesses.

However, in a March announcement, the U.S. Department of Agriculture vowed to end "taxpayer subsidies" for renewable energy, while the president's executive order targeted "market-distorting subsidies." REAP These subsidies are considered taxable income, and the USDA stated that farmers can claim them alongside federal solar tax credits. In October, the USDA announced another $8 billion in assistance for farmers facing higher fuel costs. Emergency relief may indeed be necessary. But why is it acceptable to help farmers pay for fuel costs, yet condemning them for investing in measures that could permanently reduce their energy bills?

The government also cited reasons for protecting farmland. A study by the US Department of Agriculture found that in 2020, solar and wind energy facilities directly occupied less than 0.05% of US farmland. Protecting productive land is certainly important; however, making it more difficult for rural businesses to obtain energy subsidies is another matter.

There is also a layer of political irony here. Research by Brookings has found that approximately two-thirds of the REAP subsidies flow to districts currently represented by Republicans; among the 20 districts that receive the most subsidies, 18 are controlled by Republicans. It is precisely these communities that are hit the hardest by these policies, which the government has promised to protect.

Legal issues are also serious. Congress has requested the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) to “promote” the development of renewable energy and energy efficiency in rural businesses, yet USDA’s new regulations state that the guidelines supporting this policy require it to “restrain solar energy development on farmland.” A single agency cannot rewrite the law through policy.

Farmers understand risk. Every year, they have to deal with weather, commodity prices, and an uncertain market. They shouldn't also have to guess whether Washington will change the rules after they make their investments.

A government that claims to support American business should understand a basic principle of business: your promises must be kept.

The views expressed in the comments by Fortune.com represent only the author's own opinions and do not necessarily reflect the views and positions of Fortune.

Tip
$0
Like
0
Save
0
Views 13
CoinMeta reminds readers to view blockchain rationally, stay aware of risks, and beware of virtual token issuance and speculation. All content on this site represents market information or related viewpoints only and does not constitute any form of investment advice. If you find sensitive content, please click“Report”,and we will handle it promptly。
Submit
Comment 0
Hot
Latest
No comments yet. Be the first!
Related
Overnight News on November 20: Oil Prices Volatile, S&P 500 Index Drops for Six Consecutive Days Anthropic Debut with Strong Rise Fails to Boost U.S. Stocks, Iran Increases Attacks on Tankers
Overnight market news on November 20th showed that all three major U.S. stock indices fell by more than 2%, with the Dow Jones breaking below 50,000 points, and the S&P 500 index recording a sixth consecutive day of decline; Anthropic made its debut with a 17% increase, but this was not enough to boost overall market sentiment. On a macro level, Trump's trading records from September were exposed, the U.S. Secretary of Energy stated that diesel prices in the U.S. are expected to continue to decline, and Kushner indicated that Trump is open to providing Ukraine with security guarantees similar to NATO's Article 5.
The Block
·2026-11-20 08:31:48
346
Anthropic Listing Causes Fluctuations in U.S. Stocks; AI Has the Jubilation Reached Its Peak and Is It Under New Attention?
Claude Large model developer Anthropic listed on NASDAQ, closing 17.07% higher than its issue price on the first day, with a market value briefly exceeding $2 trillion. However, all three major U.S. stock indices fell more than 2% on that day. Consequently, discussions in the market about whether the performance of AI has peaked, the returns on AI infrastructure investments, and the trends of related tech stocks have intensified.
The Block
·2026-11-20 08:22:14
307
Anthropic IPO Awards Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley $113 Million Each in Fees, Exceeding the SpaceX Listing Revenue
On Thursday, IPO brought in at least $550 million in underwriting fees for Wall Street, exceeding the $500 million raised in the SpaceX initial public offering. Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley each received $113 million, JPMorgan and Citibank estimated around $55 million each, and Wells Fargo approximately $16.5 million. On the first day, Anthropic rose by 17%, with its market value fully diluting to $1.27 trillion.
Fortune
·2026-11-20 08:10:29
284
U.S. Stock Market: S&P 500 Index Drops for Six Consecutive Days Anthropic Debut with Sharp Rise Fails to Boost Market Confidence
The S&P 500 index fell for the sixth consecutive trading day, and the upward trend in tech stocks brought about by the debut of Anthropic could not be sustained, with major stock indices turning lower.
The Block
·2026-11-20 07:32:41
343
Top 20 US stock trading volumes on November 20: Anthropic makes its debut with a 17% increase in trading volume, reaching $86.907 billion
On Thursday, Anthropic topped the list of U.S. stock market trading volume with a gain of 17.07%, trading at $86.907 billion. Many other stocks, including NVIDIA, AMD, SpaceX, Tesla, and Meta Platforms, also saw significant fluctuations. The article also mentioned Trump's disclosure of his NVIDIA holdings, a bearish report on AMD, SpaceX's plans to issue AI chip debt, as well as Intel's first external customer for its 18A process.
The Block
·2026-11-20 07:32:37
383
View More