A U.S. federal judge rejected the motions of Samsung, SK, SK Hynix, and Micron to dismiss a class-action lawsuit alleging price manipulation, finding that the conspiracy allegations raised by the plaintiffs were reasonable. These three companies together account for over 91% of global DRAM revenue, and regular DRAM prices soared by 697% over 18 months. The lawsuit may further reveal the insights behind the memory giants' production cuts and pricing strategies.
A federal judge ruled that a class action lawsuit accusing three major memory chip manufacturers of colluding to limit supply can proceed. This decision will compel Samsung Electronics, SK Hynix, and Micron Technology to disclose internal documents, and provides new legal context for the ongoing concerns about the soaring memory prices in the market.
U.S. Judge No of the Northern District Federal Court of California rejected a joint motion to dismiss filed by three defendants on November 14, ruling that the plaintiff's complaint sufficiently stated the conspiracy charges of violating Section 1 of the Sherman Act. The three companies are required to submit their defenses by December 7, after which the evidence collection process will begin. This is the most important procedural victory obtained by the plaintiff so far.
According to calculations by Goldman Sachs economist Megan Peters, the rise in memory, software, and electricity costs driven by AI has increased core PCE by more than 0.2 percentage points, and it is expected to contribute a total of 0.5 percentage points by the end of the year. Meanwhile, conventional DRAM prices have risen by 697% over 18 months, with the three defendants collectively accounting for over 91% of global DRAM revenue.

The judge ruled that "falcon formations are a legitimate form of flight," dismissing the defense argument of "repeated litigation"
This case was filed on June 25, 2025, by 17 plaintiffs, with the case number Garciaguirre v. Samsung Electronics. The plaintiffs include 14 consumers and 3 small PC manufacturers, representing all indirect purchasers of devices containing commercial DRAM. Their claims include recognition of their status as a class for collective action, injunctive relief, and triple damages.
The core defense strategy of the three defendants is to cite precedents.
In 2020, a similar lawsuit regarding the price surge from 2016 to 2018 was dismissed. In March 2022, the Ninth Circuit of Appeals upheld this decision, reasoning that the simultaneous reduction in production by three competitors was a normal parallel behavior in an oligopolistic market and did not constitute evidence of collusion. During a hearing in September, the defense argued that the new complaint was merely the same set of conspiracy theories under a different guise. Each company's decision to reduce production, switch to higher-bandwidth memory (HBM), and withdraw from DDR4 were independent profit-seeking decisions.
Wise The judge did not accept this argument. In her ruling, she clearly pointed out that there were substantial differences between this case and the circumstances involved in the 2022 ruling of the Ninth Circuit Court, and refused to dismiss the lawsuit.
During the hearing, the defendant cited the remarks of the late judge Richard Posner regarding the normal behavior of oligopolistic market competitors observing each other. In response, Wise stated that the behavior described by the plaintiff was "more like an eagle flock flying in formation" – yet flying in formation is not a natural habit of eagles. The implication of this statement is that it is legal to pay attention to the movements of competitors, but if there is a consistent pattern over three years with prices increasing eightfold, then an explanation is required.
Seven "additional factors," a customer review questionnaire with a high degree of similarity
Since parallel actions are lawful in themselves, the plaintiff must provide evidence of "additional factors," that is, actions that no rational company would undertake on its own unless it was certain that competitors would also take the same steps. The key timeline of the complaint is as follows:
- Three companies successively announced production cuts between the end of 2022 and 2023. SK Hynix and Micron took about three weeks apart in making such announcements, followed by Samsung;
- Thereafter, all three companies shifted their production capacity to HBM and signed long-term supply contracts;
- Within the second quarter of 2025, three entities announced their withdrawal from the mainstream DDR4 during that same quarter;
- In December 2025, Micron announced the closure of its consumer-grade memory brand Crucial.
- In January 2026, three companies launched customer review questionnaires with highly similar content.
Wise The judge examined each of these factors one by one. She dismissed the accusations related to DDR3 (Micron is still producing DDR3), did not credite the testimonies from investor teleconferences and industry meetings, and determined that the oligopolistic market structure itself was a neutral factor. A simple shift towards HBM was not sufficient to prove collusion, as HBM has a higher profit margin.
What truly caught the court's attention are the following points: First, despite having ample room for price adjustment, none of the three companies substantially expanded their regular production capacity. It is reported that Samsung and Micron also postponed or suspended the construction of new wafer factories. Second, all three companies signed multi-year contracts with AI customers, while Samsung and SK Hynix reportedly refused to provide long-term contracts to large regular DRAM buyers. Third, the defendants failed to provide sufficient explanations for exiting the DDR4 market during the same quarter and Micron's abandonment of the Crucial brand. Fourth, the highly similar customer review questionnaires introduced in January 2026 are what concerned the court the most, and Wise believes that this allegation "strongly supports the inference of collusion."
The court also rejected the defendant's argument that the cartel case from 1998 to 2002 was too old to be of any reference value. At that time, the case ended with a plea deal, with several executives ending up in prison, and the three companies collectively paying a fine of approximately $731 million. Micron was exempted for reporting its complicity.
The soaring memory prices have become a macroeconomic variable, and Goldman Sachs expects that new supply will not be available until 2028 at the earliest.
The reason why this case has drawn widespread attention from the market is that the abnormal trend in memory prices has penetrated to the macroeconomic level.
According to data from Goldman Sachs' Korea Technology Team (led by Giuni Lee), South Korea's DRAM exports reached a record high of $34 billion in October, a year-on-year increase of 595%; the total memory exports also increased by 359% year-on-year, for the ninth consecutive month with a growth rate exceeding 200%. TrendForce data shows that contract prices rose by about 80% in the second quarter, about 40% in the third quarter, and about 20% in the fourth quarter. The latest forecasts for PC DRAM and servers DRAM are an increase of 13% to 18% and 10% to 15%, respectively.
After hosting a roadshow for TrendForce on October 27th, Goldman Sachs maintained its buy ratings for Samsung and SK Hynix, and predicted that a meaningful increase in production capacity would be difficult to achieve before 2028. This judgment is of reference value for both parties in the lawsuit: the defendant will use it to prove that the construction cycle for wafer factories is long and that the space in clean rooms is limited; the plaintiff, on the other hand, will question why none of the three companies began construction in 2024, given that prices had already soared by then.
The impact on the demand side is also significant. Citibank expects a 15% decline in PC shipments this year, and a 12% decline in smartphones. According to a report by Goldman Sachs' South Korea team, Alibaba, Tencent, and ByteDance have approached Samsung and SK Hynix to sign 10-year server DRAM contracts – this move itself reflects a severe imbalance between market supply and demand.
The evidence collection process has been initiated, and Chinese competitors may provide a solution to the supply-side issues before the courts do.
Regarding the subsequent proceedings, the defendant is required to submit a defense statement by December 7th, and the first case management meeting is scheduled for January 12, 2027. Thereafter, the case will enter the evidence collection phase, which the defendant will strive to avoid, involving emails, chat records, and the document trail behind three customer review questionnaires. In cases from the 2000s, it was the cooperation of internal documents with Micron that ultimately laid the foundation for the charges.
However, there are two points that warrant cautious anticipation. First, the review standard during the motion to dismiss stage is merely 'reasonableness'; if a judgment is ultimately rendered in this case, the same Ninth Circuit Court will be involved in the review again. Second, even if the plaintiff wins, given the current price levels and for consumers, the time span of an antitrust proceeding, which lasts for years, makes it difficult to provide immediate relief. In terms of deterrence, the total fines imposed in cartel cases in the 2000s amounted to 731 million US dollars, while SK Hynix's quarterly operating profit is reported to have reached approximately 77 trillion Korean won.
Substantial relief on the supply side may come from outside of the courts first. Acer CEO has indicated that as China's memory manufacturer, ChangXin Technology, increases its production capacity, the supply shortage has been alleviated; TSMC is also reportedly exploring entry into the memory industry; Goldman Sachs expects ChangXin Technology's DRAM output to reach half of that of Hynix by 2028.
For memory stocks currently trading at 2 to 4 times the expected price-earnings ratio, a federal judge deemed the collusion "plausible and credible," providing a new dimension to the market's doubts about their excess profitability.
Goldman Sachs experts Peter Callahan pointed out that memory stocks are valued extremely low, but the market is increasingly concerned about their "excessive profitability." A low price-earnings ratio can serve as both an argument for bulls and bears among cyclical stocks. DRAM The spot price index has risen from less than $5 at the end of 2024 to around $53, while the expected price-earnings ratios for Micron, Samsung, and SK SK Hynix have fallen to 3.8 times, 2.6 times, and 2.2 times, respectively.











